Balboa Got a Master Plan in 2012. Stapleton is Still Searching for the File?

Published November 1, 2026

A view of Balboa Village entrance with shops and a clear blue sky.

Share this story

NEWPORT BEACH | CITY HALL WATCH | NOVEMBER 1, 2026

Newport Beach adopted the Balboa Village Master Plan in 2012. It wasn’t Joe Stapleton’s plan. He has represented District 1 since 2022, though, which is plenty of time to open a PDF—or at least ask City Hall whether the filing cabinet has a map and whether anyone has checked behind the paperwork.

The plan called for recruiting restaurants, boutique shops and other businesses, with incentives to help bring them to Balboa. The City’s vision, in other words, involved actual businesses showing up—not merely a consultant explaining where they might go someday, presumably after another study and a brief stop in “process.”

The City completed parking changes, façade grants and streetscape work. Those are real improvements. But walking through Balboa today, vacant storefronts outnumber open businesses along the route. That’s a street-level snapshot, not a formal census—and it’s a rough look for a revitalization effort whose plan specifically promised business recruitment. No consultant needed to explain the empty windows. They’ve been holding public comment for years.

A vacant commercial property with a 'For Lease' sign in the window and palm trees in the background.

At a September 2026 candidates forum, Stapleton cited the Pyle family’s roughly $100 million planned Fun Zone investment as a Balboa success story. A proposed investment may matter, but citing the number doesn’t tell residents how much has been spent, what has changed across the village, or what is happening with the plan’s promise to attract businesses throughout Balboa. A big number is not the same thing as a progress report, no matter how confidently it is carried into a forum.

The City’s Fun Zone planning record lists the application as “Applied.” The City’s January 2025 project list said the application had been deemed incomplete twice and that a traffic study had begun. The project file has a status. Residents still need a clear account of the schedule, the money committed and the results promised for the rest of Balboa. “Applied” is a status; it is not, by itself, a ribbon-cutting.

A red building with a black awning and a bench in front, featuring a one-way sign and potted plants.

Joe didn’t write the 2012 plan. He inherited the district—and the responsibility to ask what became of its unfinished work. Has he reviewed the business-recruitment goals? What has he asked the City to do about the vacancies? Where is the count of businesses opened, businesses closed and storefronts still empty? And where is the current plan to change those numbers? Those are basic questions, not an exotic request for the City to locate the lost civilization of follow-through.

A vacant storefront with a 'For Lease' sign and a clear blue sky in the background.

City Hall can keep looking for the file. Balboa’s storefront windows are already displaying the progress report. Unfortunately, the report is mostly glass.

This story is checked every 3 days for its first 30 days. When there’s news, we add a dated update here. How we keep stories current →

Balboa Got a Master Plan in 2012. Stapleton is Still Searching for the File?

Help us out, Newport.

Read next

Surf Report